Why Auto Repair Shops Are Now the Hardest Employers to Staff in the Skilled Trades

If you hire technicians, you already know how hard it is to fill a bay. Garages in the US and the UK are struggling to find qualified people, and jobs stay open for months.

Other trades have shortages too, but auto repair is harder to staff. The role has changed. Technicians now need diagnostic, ADAS, and EV skills, and those skills do not transfer easily from one technician to the next.

This guide is for employers and recruiters. It covers:

  • How big the technician gap is

  • Why the job is harder to fill than it used to be

  • What to fix in your job specs

  • Why technicians leave, and how to keep them

The Numbers

TechForce Foundation’s 2026 report shows a clear gap in the US:

  • 70,865 technician openings each year

  • 50,085 new technicians entering the trade

  • About 20,780 jobs left unfilled every year

From independent garages to franchised dealers and fleet operators, the same small group of technicians is being pursued.

The takeaway? Demand for technicians is outpacing supply.

Why Auto Repair is Different

Every skilled trade is short of workers. Auto repair has an extra problem: the job changed, but the title stayed the same.

 

Technician in 2015

Technician in 2026

Core skill

Mechanical repair

Mechanical repair plus diagnostics

Software

Basic diagnostic tools

Scan data across many vehicle platforms

Safety systems

Rarely needed 

ADAS calibration is routine

Electric vehicles

Rare

High voltage work is growing 

 

The candidate pool did not just get smaller. It split into specialisms that do not transfer:

  • A diesel drivetrain expert may have no ADAS experience.

  • A new EV specialist may lack the breadth to run a general bay.

  • One job title now covers five or six different roles.

Recruiters are no longer filling one job. They are filling several, under one label.

Mistakes in Technician Job Specs

Most technician job ads still say “experienced, qualified, reliable.” Onrec’s article on safety certification gaps explains why this wording is a problem. It hides the credential gap.

“Qualified” could mean a decade-old certificate, a general apprenticeship, or a current EV credential. Strong candidates cannot tell if the role fits them. Weak candidates apply anyway.

What to Put in the Spec Instead

  • Scan platforms: 

Name the diagnostic tools your shop uses, such as OEM software or a multi-brand platform. Say whether the job includes module work too, such as diagnosing a failed PCM and fitting replacement car computers from Car Computer Exchange.

  • ADAS calibration: 

Say if it is part of the job. If you outsource it, say that too.

  • High-voltage certification: 

Say if it is required on day one or if you will pay for it.

  • UK example: an IMI-recognised EV qualification.

  • US example: an ASE or manufacturer pathway.

A funded route into EV work is one of the strongest offers an employer can make right now.

Why the Cost of a Bad Hire is Higher Here

Onrec has covered why skilled trades are the hardest roles to fill. Auto repair is the sharpest example because equipment costs sit on top of salary costs.

  • Scan tools

  • Calibration rigs

  • EV-rated lifts

  • Insulated tooling

Hire the wrong technician, and you pay for capability you cannot use. Lose the right one and that investment sits idle.

Why Technicians Leave

Hiring is hard. Keeping people is harder, and the cause is often not what recruiters expect.

Many technicians are paid on a flat rate. A similar productivity-based system is fairly common among dealerships and larger independent garages in the UK. Wages are based on hours booked, not hours clocked.

The system works, but it creates one common problem:

  1. A technician has a slow week.

  2. They cannot see why. Was it their pace, or too little work in the bay?

  3. They start to suspect the shop.

  4. They start looking for another job.

Pay disputes drive more turnover in this trade than pay level does. Many technicians will accept a lower rate of pay if they trust how it is determined. Many will leave a better-paid job if they do not.

Make the Numbers Visible

Shops that use auto repair shop scheduling software can show each technician their booked hours against clocked hours in real time. The technician can see whether the bay is feeding them work instead of guessing.

This changes the talk with the service manager. It stops being an argument about whose figures are right. Both sides look at the same data. For HR teams, that means a common grievance gets spotted and fixed before it turns into a resignation.

What Employers Can Control

The training pipeline is fixed for years. A recruitment campaign is not going to help bridge a 20,780 job deficit. One lever remains in your hands: the technicians that you have already hired.

  • Write job specs that name the systems and credentials.

  • Fund the ADAS and high-voltage training that makes a technician scarce and valuable.

  • Make pay transparent so nobody has to wonder if the numbers are right.

Every open role costs months of lost capacity. In this market, retention is the most practical staffing plan a shop has.

Conclusion

The job of the auto repair technician is the most difficult skilled trade to fill because the job has evolved quicker than hiring. Pools are small, fragmented, and not expanding quickly enough to satisfy demand.

You can’t do anything about the national shortfall, but you can fix the way you hire and retain. Be very specific about what is required for the role. Cover the cost of training for scarce skills.

Every open bay costs you capacity, and every technician who leaves takes skills that are hard to replace. In this market, keeping a good technician is the best hire you can make.

 
Recruitment Spotlight: the people shaping recruitment. Read the interviews.The Onrec Awards: a night for the remarkable. March 2027. Explore the Awards.

Community poll

When should employers first share salary information with candidates?